|
-Access To Adoption Records-
State
laws differ in how they handle access to information in sealed
adoption records. This document explains and summarizes the types
of information made available under State law. Those wishing to
access records are encouraged to investigate the laws in the State
where the adoption was finalized. For a summary of your State's
adoption laws on access to adoption records please see "Access to
Adoption Records State by State."
Types of Information Made Available
Non-identifying information is generally restricted to
descriptive details about the adopted adult and the adopted
adult's birth relatives. Policies on what information is collected
varies from State to State along with the maintenance and
disclosure of that information. The information can include any of
the following items:
-
Date and place of the adopted adult's birth
-
Age of the birth parents and a description of their general
physical appearances
-
Race, ethnicity, religion, and medical history of the birth
parents
-
Type of termination
-
Facts and circumstances relating to the adoptive placement
-
Age and sex of children of the birth parents at the time of
adoption
-
Educational levels of the birth parents and their occupations,
interests, skills
-
Any supplemental information about the medical or social
conditions of members of the birth family provided since the
adoption was complete.
Medical
history is only rarely updated, making the information as old as
the adopted adult. Past records may contain very sparse
information collected at the time of the adoption either due to
hesitancy of birth mothers to disclose information or to the lack
of importance given to this information by adoption agencies,
private facilitators, and lawyers. State laws now require
collection of more information at the time of the adoption for
full disclosure of heath and background information to the
adoptive parents.
Identifying information is considered to be data which may
lead to the positive identification of an adopted adult, birth
mother, or birth father. Names, addresses, and dates contained in
court records or submitted to the State Department of Vital
Statistics are usually considered identifying information.
Listed below are several ways that triad members can obtain
identifying information according to their State laws.
Original Birth Certificate
The original birth certificate is only one of the many
documents contained within the adoptee's adoption record. Most
state laws do not allow adoptees access to their original birth
certificate. A few states allow adoptees restricted access to
their birth certificate depending on their date of birth, whether
the birth parents have filed a consent for release, and/or the
birth parents have not filed a request for non-disclosure.
Adopted adults 18 or older have unrestricted access to their
original birth certificate in Alaska and Kansas. Tennessee and
Oregon have provisions allowing access to original birth
certificates for adopted adults, and at the same time allowing
birth parents to state if they wish to not to be contacted by the
adopted person. A number of states, including Alabama, Colorado,
Maryland, Nebraska, Ohio and Wisconsin, give adopted adults access
to their original birth certificates when a prior consent for the
birth parent(s) is on file. Access may also depend on the date of
adoption. Delaware gives adopted adults access to original birth
certificates unless a request for non-disclosure is on file. In
Montana, Vermont and Washington, some adopted adults have access
to original birth certificates unless a request for non-disclosure
is on file, but access depends on the date of adoption.
Systems for Accessing Information
Registries allow adopted adults, birth parents, and
sometimes birth siblings and adoptive parents to consent or not
consent to have their identifying information released. Registry
procedures vary greatly from State to State. In some States the
registry is centralized in the State government and in others it
operates across the State through the agencies or courts that
handled the adoption. Also some States will not release
information to a requesting party if the other party is deceased
or information will not be released if the adopted adult has not
received the permission of the adoptive parents. These registries
are many times referred to as passive registries. Passive
registries, also known as mutual consent or
volunteer registries, require both parties to register their
consent for release of information before a match can be made.
Once a match occurs, both parties are notified. These systems
depend upon parties registering, a match being found, and the
follow-up notification by a registry administrator. Many times
parties are not aware of the registry or they are unable to
register. A passive registry has a match rate of about 10%.
Search and consent procedures authorize a public or private
agency to assist a searching party in locating triad members to
determine if they consent to the release of identifying
information or to meeting with the requesting party. If consent is
given, then information identifying the party being sought may
then be disclosed if authorized by the court. In many States
counseling is often required before information is received. Some
States have search and consent procedures called confidential
intermediary systems. States with confidential intermediary
systems have an individual called a Confidential intermediary
who is sanctioned by the courts and has access to sealed adoption
files for the purpose of conducting a search. The confidential
intermediaries are hired by the inquiring party to conduct
searches for an adopted adult or birth parent, make contact with
each party, and obtain each person's consent or denial for the
release of information. Depending on the particular laws of the
State or county, contact may be attempted once after a specific
time period or the file may close permanently if the party who is
being sought is not found. A few registries also fall under search
and consent procedures. Once one party is registered, a designated
individual (often an agency or court representative) is assigned
to contact those persons being sought and determine their wishes
for the release of information. These registries sometimes are
referred to as active registries. These registries have a
match rate of between 50-90%.
Affidavit System
In an affidavit system parties can give prior written
permission affirming their consent to the release of identifying
information by placing an affidavit detailing that permission in
the adoption file. This written permission may be referred to as a
consent, waiver or authorization form. The affidavit system is
commonly used along with the search and consent system.
Veto System
A veto is a document filed by one party to the adoption in
which the person registers a refusal to be contacted or for
release of identifying information. In an access veto or
nondisclosure request system, an adopted adult may receive
identifying information about another party if no veto is on file.
In a contact veto system, a seeking party is permitted
access to identifying information, including an original birth
certificate, but is prohibited from contacting the other parties.
Court Orders
Most States in which the adoption records are sealed allow an
adopted adult to petition the court to receive identifying
information. In these cases "good cause" must be proven to the
court in order for the information to be given. The definition of
good cause varies widely depending on the judge or State.
Variations may include:
-
Good cause as demonstrated by clear and convincing evidence
-
Good cause shown in exceptional cases
-
A showing that the release of information is in the best
interest of the child or the public
-
Health or medical reasons
-
Showing of compelling reasons
-
Showing that disclosure would be of greater benefit than
non-disclosure
Summary of State Legislation
This short summary provides information on bills submitted in
State legislatures regarding access to adoption records.
-
Alabama: House Bill 690, allows adopted adults age 19
or older a copy of their original birth certificate as well
as the other documents maintained with the original record,
was signed into law by the Governor May 25, 2000.
-
Arkansas: House Bill 2202, which would allow adopted
adults age 21 or older to receive the original birth
certificate. On March 8, 1999 it was filed in the house. The
Bill died in committee on March 30, 1999.
-
Colorado: House Bill 1188 was signed into law by the
Governor and took effect on July 1, 1999. For adoptions
finalized after September 1, 1999, an adopted adult 18 years
or older will automatically have access to original birth
records unless a birth parent has filed a confidentiality
request within three years of relinquishment. For adoptions
finalized prior to September 1, 1999, birth parents and
adopted adults will have access to original birth records by
mutual consent.
-
Connecticut: Senate Bill 1274 allows adopted adults
at age 18, whose adoptions were finalized prior to October
1, 1977, to access a copy of their original birth
certificate. For adoptions finalized after October 1, 1977,
the adopted adult must petition Probate Court. The bill was
defeated in the 1999 legislative session.
-
Delaware: House Bill 522 allows adopted adults age 21
or older to receive a copy of their original birth
certificate if no veto is filed by the birth parent. House
Bill 522 has been passed and signed into law.
-
Illinois: House Bill 631 creates the Illinois
Adoption Registry and Medical Information Exchange. It is
waiting to be signed by the Governor.
-
Montana: House Bill 163 allows persons adopted prior
to July 1, 1967 to obtain a copy of their original birth
certificate upon request. The bill has been signed into law.
-
North Carolina: House Bill 286 regards access to
adoption records and a registry for North Carolina. On June
15, 1999 it was defeated.
-
Oregon: Measure 58 allows adopted adults age 21 or older
access to their original birth certificate went into effect
May 30, 2000 after the U.S. Supreme Court refused to review
the law. In accordance with this recent legislation, a law
has been passed allowing birth parents to file a form
stating they do not wish to be contacted.
-
Tennessee: Tennessee enacted new statutory provisions
and amendments that would allow adopted adults 21 or older
born after March 16, 1951 access to their adoption records
which includes their original birth certificate. This
legislation also allows a contact veto to be filed by birth
parent and birth relatives to prevent contact by the adopted
adult. This legislation went into effect September 27, 1999
when the U.S. Supreme Court refused to review the law.
-
Texas: House Bill 13 allows adopted adults age 21 or
older to receive a copy of their original birth certificate.
On March 1, 1999 the House left it pending in committee.
|